Both came out of gray eggs. So it's a chance you'll hatch olive, gray, blue, green or whatever your hen lays. I have a black Feather olive egger rooster. He just came into man hood yesterday. He is very nice to look at. I'm not sure how he'll turn out personality wise. Toby I have a gray Feather Gray olive egger rooster. He's very good with the girls and keeps his distance with me. He was a shy boy growing up and is a good rooster. Gray boy in photos I couldn't find black one. Not firm on price but willing to trade for an Apple or similar. They're just not worthless. I was able to sell Toby's eggs for $25 a Fertilized dozen. %99 fertile He was over my Easter eggers. Also for sale. If proven gray eggers this spring you can sell his eggs for more.